She Slept With Someone Else Before Our Date: How to Handle This Situation

September 21, 2023

Dating in the modern age can be tricky to navigate. With endless options available through dating apps and websites, it's common for singles to go on dates with multiple people at once before deciding to be exclusive. This can lead to some awkward situations, like finding out your new date slept with someone else right before meeting up with you.

What's the right way to handle this news? Here's some guidance on reacting maturely, having an open discussion, and deciding if you want to continue seeing this person.

Don't Overreact Initially

If you find out a date slept with someone else shortly before meeting up with you, it can be shocking or hurtful. But remember, you weren't exclusive yet, so try not to overreact right away. Take a moment to process the information calmly. Reflect on whether your expectations of exclusivity were realistic given the newness of your connection.

Passing judgment or reacting with extreme anger or sadness may push this person away unnecessarily. Reserve your reaction until you've had time to think it over with a level head.

Have an Open Conversation

Once you've gotten over the initial surprise, have an honest discussion with your date. There's likely a simple explanation for their actions, so don't assume the worst.

Ask them about their views on dating and relationships. Do they typically see multiple people at once before committing to someone? Are they interested in eventually being exclusive with you? Their answers will help you determine if your outlooks align.

Share your own perspectives as well. Explain whether you prefer to only date one person at a time and your ideal timeline for exclusivity. Working through this together in a mature, non-judgmental way will set you up for open communication going forward.

Consider Your Dealbreakers

Ultimately, decide if their actions are a dealbreaker for you or not. Reflect on your must-haves for a healthy relationship and whether this person still meets them.

For some, dating multiple people until exclusivity is discussed is perfectly normal and wouldn't negatively impact their interest. Others may view intimacy as something only shared between exclusive partners.

Determine your own boundaries and whether this revelation crosses them. If you realize you have incompatible perspectives on dating, it's better to walk away now rather than try to force a relationship that doesn't align with your values.

Prioritize Sexual Health

No matter whether you choose to continue seeing this person or not, make sure you're protecting your sexual health. Since they recently slept with someone else, it's wise to use protection, get tested, and have an open conversation about your health status. Don't make assumptions - better to be safe.

Discussing sexual health early on sets a precedent of maturity and transparency for any relationship.

Reflect on Modern Dating Norms

Try not to take their actions personally. Dating culture today is much less structured than in the past. Many people see nothing wrong with casually dating or being intimate with multiple partners until they decide to be exclusive.

Rather than judging others, reflect on what dating norms and boundaries make you comfortable. Stick to those values when getting to know new people. That way, you'll organically find someone who shares your preferences.

Discovering a new date wasn't on the same page can be awkward. But by handling the situation with empathy, discretion, and self-awareness, you can turn it into an opportunity for open communication and growth. The right mindset and perspective makes all the difference.

Work with a Filteroff Matchmaker

Tired of sifting through endless profiles and swiping on dating apps in 2024?

It's time to let a professional Matchmaker do the heavy lifting for you!

Each Filteroff Matchmaker has over 10+ years of proven success in executive matchmaking, ensuring you'll receive curated, high-quality video dates.

Book your free consultation call below and start video dating today!

Here's what you'll get:

✓ Personal human matchmaker
✓ Intake session
✓ Unlimited dating coaching
✓ Unlimited video dates
✓ 90% cheaper than traditional matchmaking services
✓ No swiping, no endless chats

Book Matchmaking Call
*Got questions? Book a consultation call with one of our specialists here